Nimble Forum


Still need a gudgeon

Posted By: Brent - N20
Date: 2/2/08 6:09p.m.

Report: outside forum guidelines

In Response To: gudgeon (Gene Halpern ex-Nimble 20)

Actually, this wasn't a particularly light grounding. More of the "beating the rudder against the bottom in a surf zone" kind of night. Combination of a shoal where I wasn't expecting one, wind way worse than forecast and some wrap-around waves that hit me when I thought I was protected. As far as I could tell, the anchor didn't drag, but the extra 20' of rode I let out when I woke to wind screaming in the rigging and waves rocking my world was enough to put the rudder in danger. "Knowing" that I was in four feet of water slowed my recognition of the 'new noise' as grounding long enough to doom the gudgeon (and any chance of rest for the next 12 hours).

So I got the gudgeon back from the fabricator yesterday and I'm not happy. Two friends recommended this guy, but this doesn't seem to be what he's good at. I'll put it back on the boat and go sailing until I get a better solution, but it's ugly, doesn't fit well (I left him the boat to measure against) and the reinforcements will just move the stress points to another weak point. And I'll probably have to dremel the welds to get the screws to bed. Ack!

Anyone want to post photos/details of their elegant solution or go in on a nice bronze casting? Are the scantlings on the 24 and any other models the same as the 20?

-Brent (Nimble 20, Morgan Truce)

Messages In This Thread

Busted Gudgeon Club -- Brent - N20 -- 1/27/08 4:16p.m.
Rd: Busted Gudgeon -- Paul Miller, Nimble 20, Deland, FL -- 1/27/08 5:24p.m.
Gudgeon -- Ed, N24, Sarasota -- 1/28/08 3:04a.m.
suspect so -- Brent - N20 -- 2/8/08 1:25p.m.
Brent, my break was same as yours... -- Paul Miller, Nimble 20, Deland, FL -- 2/8/08 4:07p.m.
Gudgeons -- Ed, N24, Sarasota -- 2/8/08 6:41p.m.
Pict of mine.. -- Mark N, Nimble Arctic, Jax FL -- 2/8/08 8:39p.m.
looks like you're safe -- Brent - N20 -- 2/9/08 10:41a.m.
gudgeon -- Gene Halpern ex-Nimble 20 -- 2/2/08 4:52p.m.
 Still need a gudgeon   -- Brent - N20 -- 2/2/08 6:09p.m.
N "20" pentalls and gudgeons -- Jim -- 2/2/08 7:09p.m.
Phillips heads aren't screws -- Brent - N20 -- 2/9/08 4:08p.m.
Peanuts -- Gene Halpern ex-Nimble 20 -- 2/9/08 8:01p.m.
Good idea -- I've been considering an inner tube -- Paul Miller, Nimble 20, Deland, FL -- 2/10/08 5:19a.m.
flotation -- Gene Halpern ex-Nimble 20 -- 2/10/08 1:47p.m.
p&g's -- scott barnes, n20 -- 2/2/08 10:05p.m.

 

Post Response

Your Name:
Your E-Mail Address:
Subject:
Message

Is your topic political? If so, be sure you're posting in The Political Corner

Click here for help on smiley faces and formatting codes

If you'd like to include a link to another page with your message,
please provide both the URL address and the title of the page:

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:

If you'd like to include an image (picture) with your message,
please provide the URL address of the image file:

You may upload a file to our server by clicking here.

Optional Image URL:

Please these four characters into the field below. Do not enter spaces, just numbers and letters.
 

 

Nimble Sailboats Forum is maintained by SailboatOwners.com with WebBBS 5.12.