Santana/Schock Forum


Seth, 1st off, beyond my experience. That being said...

Posted By: Gary, Santana 2023A, Milwaukee
Date: 7/1/08 12:00p.m.

Report: outside forum guidelines

In Response To: Thanks (pic) (Seth Dabney, 2023-C, Oxford, MS)

my '2023A' is laid out differently. While I have what I believe to be 'typical' aging cracks here and there... nothing like what you have shown above. So, keeping in mind that you are the one on the scene to best evaluate it, I think I find it hard to believe that it would be seperating right at that spot, and right in that manner. Yes, it very well may be occuring that way, and I can certainly understand the rational and thought processing which you've laid out. However, I do believe that I would have to investigate it further, probably chipping all that stuff out of the way, get a better/clearer picture of the situation. See, here's my thought... which, simply by its nature of being a 'thought', is every bit as valid as your thinking, until the 'real' deal is discovered.

You remember my telling you a while back at my shock at the poor (labor) quality of work done on the inside of the WB tank? Horribly POOR carpentry work, wood fitting, gaps, etc? As if "Nobody can see in here, and it's going to be covered by epoxy, anyway..." ??

Well, I'd be just as inclined to think, 50-50 along with yours... what if that bulkhead (plate) of wood was poorly cut and fitted, so that there's, oh, say a 1/4" gap between the top of its fit? Hell, it's covered by cloth and epoxy, anyway. So, if it did 'crack', and you/we are unaware of this, a simple look would SEEM to indicate that the overhead was pulling away from the top of the bulkhead.

More simply put: how positive are you that its pulling/seperating away?

I see the gap, and I see where you filled it. Is it possible this is simple aging with a poor OEM carpentry fitting?

Messages In This Thread

Speaking about the structural integrity of a 2023 -- Seth Dabney, 2023-C, Oxford, MS -- 6/30/08 12:07p.m.
Mines not. -- Bob Frak -- 6/30/08 9:05p.m.
Thanks -- Seth Dabney, 2023-C, Oxford, MS -- 6/30/08 10:08p.m.
 Seth, 1st off, beyond my experience. That being said...  -- Gary, Santana 2023A, Milwaukee -- 7/1/08 12:00p.m.
After thinking... -- Bob Frak -- 7/1/08 8:19p.m.
Crack -- George E Norkus, Santana 2023A, SE Michigan -- 7/1/08 9:03p.m.
thanks for the ideas -- Seth Dabney, 2023-C, Oxford, MS -- 7/1/08 9:47p.m.
Seth, yes about the wood core and should you... -- George E Norkus, Santana 2023A, SE Michigan -- 7/2/08 12:45p.m.
You mentioned it when routing your M/head wires through alum compression post. -- Gary, Santana 2023A, Milwaukee -- 7/2/08 12:58p.m.
current ideas -- Seth Dabney, 2023-C, Oxford, MS -- 7/3/08 10:14a.m.
Well, Bob, almost time for the North Channel. -- Gary, Santana 2023A, Milwaukee -- 7/2/08 3:21p.m.
Hello Gary -- Bob Frak -- 7/5/08 7:01a.m.

 

Post Response

Your Name:
Your E-Mail Address:
Subject:
Message

Is your topic political? If so, be sure you're posting in The Political Corner

Click here for help on smiley faces and formatting codes

If you'd like to include a link to another page with your message,
please provide both the URL address and the title of the page:

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:

If you'd like to include an image (picture) with your message,
please provide the URL address of the image file:

You may upload a file to our server by clicking here.

Optional Image URL:

Please type these four characters into the field below. Do not enter spaces, just numbers and letters.
 

 

Santana/Schock Forum is maintained by SailboatOwners.com with WebBBS 5.12.